Tooth Fairy Gift Ideas for a Magical First Tooth Loss

I didn’t think much about tooth fairy gift ideas until my son lost his first tooth—and I had nothing ready.

I ended up printing a quick letter, adding glitter to a dollar, and slipping it under his pillow.

The look on his face the next morning made me want to do more next time.

Since then, I’ve pulled together some of the most fun, thoughtful, and simple ways to make Tooth Fairy visits feel a little more magical—without a ton of prep.

**This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and a participant in other affiliate programs, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.**

Gifts from the Tooth Fairy

Once we moved beyond just leaving a dollar, I realized how fun it could be to get creative with Tooth Fairy surprises.

My son still talks about the tiny note she left with sparkly dust, or the time she brought a gold coin “from her treasure box.”

If you’re looking for fun and memorable ideas, these gifts from the Tooth Fairy add a little extra magic to an already special moment.

Keepsake and Personalized Gifts

The first time the Tooth Fairy came to our house, I wanted it to feel like more than just a transaction—something my son would remember. These keepsake and personalized gifts turned out to be our favorites because they felt special, not just for the night, but long after.

1. Tooth Fairy Personalized Pillows: We started with a little pillow that had a tooth pocket and my son’s name stitched on it. He loved it so much he slept with it even when no teeth were loose. These pillows make it easy for the Tooth Fairy to find the tooth and leave a surprise.
2. Personalized Tooth Fairy Kit: One year, we found a sweet kit with a wand, fairy dust, and a custom note. The pastel colors made it feel magical, and it became part of our nighttime routine whenever a wiggly tooth was close.
3. Engraved Boxes: We didn’t have one of these when my son started losing teeth, but I’ve seen how cute they can be. They’re great for kids who like to keep track of their lost teeth, and they make a sweet keepsake for parents too.

Fun and Practical Gifts

Some of our favorite Tooth Fairy moments have come from the simplest ideas. It doesn’t always need to be a big gift—just something small and thoughtful that keeps the magic going. These are a few fun and practical things we’ve used (and loved) over the years:

1. Tooth Fairy Letter Printable: The first time I forgot to prep anything, I quickly printed a letter, added a little glitter, and called it fairy dust. He believed it 100%, and now the printable letter is part of our tradition.
2. Tooth Fairy Envelope Template: We’ve used these to tuck the tooth in safely, especially when it’s bedtime chaos. A tiny envelope with cute details makes the exchange feel official.
3. Fairy Door: We added a miniature door on his nightstand, and it instantly turned the whole thing into a story. Now he imagines the Tooth Fairy walking through it while he sleeps. It’s been a favorite part of the tradition.
4. Tooth Fairy Stationery: If you have a kid who loves reading little notes (like mine), this is a great way to make each visit feel personal. I’ll sometimes write them from the Tooth Fairy’s “desk” just for fun.

Creative and Crafty Gifts

If your child loves hands-on fun, these Tooth Fairy gift ideas bring in a bit of creativity. My son enjoys crafting, so we started using some of these when he lost a tooth—turns out, the prep was just as fun as the surprise.

1. Lost My First Tooth Ornaments: I still have the one we made with the date of his first lost tooth. It’s now part of our Christmas decorations, and he points it out every year. A simple keepsake, but it holds a lot of memory.
2. Tooth Fairy Craft Kits: We tried one with fairy glitter, tiny jars, and stickers. He ended up making a little “fairy home” from a tissue box too. These kits let kids be part of the magic, especially if they’re into creating things.

These crafty touches are great if you want to make the experience more interactive—especially with kids who like to do things their own way.

Comfort and Bedtime Gifts

Losing a tooth can be exciting—but also a little nerve-wracking, especially the first time. We found that adding something cozy or calming helped make bedtime feel a little more special on Tooth Fairy nights.

1. Blankets and Towels: One year, my son got a soft blanket with tiny stars on it “from the Tooth Fairy.” He still calls it his fairy blanket. It wasn’t fancy, just a comforting touch that tied into the magic.
2. Nightlights and Lamps: A small fairy light or gentle nightlight can be perfect for kids who are a bit anxious at bedtime. We used one shaped like a moon, and he was convinced it helped the Tooth Fairy find her way.

These gifts are simple, but they helped make the night feel cozy and calm—especially when the excitement made it hard to fall asleep.

Practical Dental Health Gifts

I figured if the Tooth Fairy was already making a visit, it was the perfect time to sneak in something useful too. These little gifts made brushing more fun and felt like part of the celebration instead of a chore.

1. Toothbrush Sets: We’ve given a few character-themed toothbrushes as “Tooth Fairy tools,” and my son was genuinely excited to use them. Pairing them with matching toothpaste or a fun cup made it feel like a reward.
2. Brushing Timers: These were a game-changer. One visit included a simple sand timer, and suddenly brushing for two minutes became a fun challenge.

We also used some of our dental health color by number printables around this time—they were a great way to talk about tooth care without it feeling like a lecture.

Thoughtful and Unusual Gifts

Some of our most memorable Tooth Fairy visits have come from the unexpected stuff—the little extras that made my son pause and say, “Wait… how did she know I’d like this?”

• Tooth Fairy Books – The Untold Story of the Tooth Fairy became a bedtime favorite after we used it as a gift one night. It helped answer all his questions about how the Tooth Fairy actually does her job.
• Fairy Jewelry or Trinkets – One time I left a tiny charm bracelet in a little pouch, and he decided it was part of the Fairy’s treasure collection. Small, inexpensive, but magical in the moment.
• Glitter Jars – We’ve made our own “fairy jars” with glow-in-the-dark glitter and water. He kept his on his dresser for weeks. They’re easy to make and feel straight out of a fairy tale.

These kinds of gifts don’t happen every time, but sprinkling in a surprise here and there keeps the tradition fun—for both of us.

No matter how many teeth your child has left to lose, adding a little creativity to the tradition can make it something they’ll actually remember.

Some nights we keep it simple, other times we go all out—but every visit from the Tooth Fairy has become a small moment we both look forward to.

Whether it’s a handwritten note, a keepsake gift, or just a sprinkle of glitter, the magic is in the effort.

Last Updated on 7 April 2025 by Clare Brown