125 Awesome Non-Candy Easter Egg Filler Ideas for Plastic Eggs

Like What You See? Tell Your Friends!

I love a good old-fashioned Easter egg hunt, but I always struggled to know what to put in them! Well not anymore. This year I have created this list of 125 awesome non-candy easter egg filler ideas for your plastic eggs.

I have split this huge list into sections:

  • Unisex
  • Fidget toys
  • Girls Easter Egg Fillers
  • Boys Easter Egg Fillers
  • Healthy Snacks

We have created free Easter scavenger hunt clues that you can print out and make the hunt more interesting. Also, why not print out our free Easter bunny footprint template and really bring the magic.

**There may be affiliate links in this post. If you make a purchase (after clicking one of my affiliate links) I’ll earn some coffee money, which I promise to drink while supporting your journey. You do not pay a higher price. You can read my full disclosure at the bottom of the page.**

All 125 Easter egg fillers listed will actually fit in a plastic egg. We tend to buy a mixture of sized eggs though, large plastic eggs, medium plastic eggs, and small plastic eggs. What I love about buying these is that I only need to buy them once. When the kids have found their gift keep the eggs and put them away for next year.

Easter Egg Filler

easter egg filler ideas

All of these Easter egg fillers are unisex, so perfect if you are having a large Easter Egg hunt with lots of children, If you are having an Easter egg hunt for just girls or boys though I have listed these fillers at the end of this post.

  1. Marbles
  2. Puffy Stickers
  3. Dice
  4. Dig gem box
  5. Temporary tattoos
  6. Rubber wrist bracelets
  7. Inflatable beach ball
  8. Rainbow shoe laces
  9. Whistle
  10. Easter scratch off cards
  11. Easter Erasers
  12. Zoo animal finger puppets
  13. Kid’s Earbuds
  14. Toy insects
  15. Farm animals
  16. Funky shaped bandaids
  17. Pencil Top Erasers
  18. Silly Bandz Pets
  19. Mini play dough
  20. Elastic no-tie shoelaces
  21. Bunny shaped bookmark clip
  22. Finger lights
  23. Mini chalkboard
  24. Diving buddies
  25. Washi tape 
  26. Mini flashlight
  27. Mini stamp
  28. Glow in the dark stars
  29. Sticky hands
  30. Mini lego set
  31. Balloons
  32. Punch balloon
  33. Lego minifigures
  34. Water Balloons
  35. Grow an animal capsules
  36. Miniature rubber ducky
  37. Wind up baby chicks
  38. Mini chalk
  39. Bendable animals
  40. Dinosaur fossils
  41. Rocks & Fossils
  42. Buildable crayons
  43. Lanyard
  44. Mini yo-yo
  45. Easter magnets
  46. Easter charms
  47. Mini notebook
  48. Coins (actual money)
easter egg fillers lego

Fidget Toy Easter Egg Filler Ideas

  1. Mini pop it keychain
  2. Pop it bracelet
  3. Play foam
  4. Stringy ball
  5. Stress ball
  6. Inflatable beach ball
  7. Squishes
  8. Galaxy slime
  9. Mesh ball
  10. Puzzle balls
  11. Mini Rubix cube
  12. Spring coils
  13. Fidget snake twist
  14. Mini fidget spinner
  15. Thinking putty
  16. Mini expandable sphere
  17. Splash ball for the pool
  18. Mini bubbles
  19. Mini puzzle box
  20. Bouncy ball
  21. Super splashers

Girls Easter Egg Fillers

girls easter egg fillers
  1. Hair ties
  2. Easter nail stickers
  3. Scrunchies
  4. Chapstick
  5. Hair bows
  6. Non-toxic nail polish
  7. Disney Princess Coin purse
  8. Bandana
  9. Easter Slap bracelet
  10. Backpack keychains
  11. Disney Earrings
  12. Colorful hairclips
  13. Jelly bracelets
  14. Stick on earrings 
  15. Elastic Headband 
  16. Friendship bracelet
  17. Mini trolls
  18. Beaded necklace
  19. Friendship zipper bracelets
  20. Unicorn Beaded bracelet
  21. Lip gloss
  22. Mermaid headband
  23. Mini Disney characters
  24. Light up ring
  25. Body glitter
  26. Hair chalk
Over 125 non candy easter egg fillers

Boys Easter Egg Filler Ideas

  1. NBA bracelet
  2. Star Wars socks
  3. Matchbox cars
  4. Bath bombs for boys
  5. Mini whoopie cushion
  6. Toy soldiers
  7. Superhero slap bracelet
  8. Parachute men
  9. Pirate treasure
  10. Water squirt toy
  11. Insect finger puppet
  12. Pull back cars or trucks
  13. Monster socks
  14. Popper spring launchers
  15. Mini transformers

Non Candy Egg Fillers

easter fruit
  1. Goldfish
  2. Fruit – grapes
  3. Annie’s Cheddar Bunnies 
  4. Mini Pretzels
  5. Raisins
  6. Yogurt Covered Pretzels 
  7. Popcorn
  8. Cheerios
  9. Yogurt Covered Raisins
  10. Animal Crackers 
  11. Pirate’s Booty puffs
  12. Fruit by the Foot
  13. Teddy Grahams
  14. Chips
  15. Bunny Fruit Snacks

If you are looking for regular-sized Easter gifts check out our most popular Easter gift guides:

Last Updated on 13 April 2022 by homeschoolof1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.