125 Healthy Easter Egg Fillers Kids Will Love
If you’re looking to cut back on candy this Easter, healthy Easter egg fillers are a great way to keep things fun without the sugar overload.
We’ve used a mix of better-for-you snacks and creative non-candy items over the years—like mini games, craft supplies, and small toys—and they’ve always been a hit.
Whether you’re avoiding food allergies, added sugar, or just want something different, these healthy Easter egg ideas are a fun and practical option for any egg hunt.
**This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and a participant in other affiliate programs, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.**
Healthy Easter Egg Stuffers
Looking for healthy Easter egg fillers that kids will actually be excited about? These snack ideas are a fun and nutritious twist on the usual candy overload.
From simple fruits to crunchy favorites, these savory and sweet treats are perfect for plastic eggs—and most are allergy-friendly and easy to portion.
Savory Snack Options
- Goldfish
- Fruit – grapes
- Annie’s Cheddar Bunnies
- Mini Pretzels
- Raisins
- Yogurt Covered Pretzels
- Popcorn
- Cheerios
Tip: Wrap items like grapes or popcorn in cling film or small food-safe bags before adding them to eggs.
Sweet Treats
- Yogurt Covered Raisins
- Animal Crackers
- Pirate’s Booty Puffs
- Fruit by the Foot
- Teddy Grahams
- Chips
- Bunny Fruit Snacks
Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers
Healthy Easter egg fillers don’t have to be all about snacks.
These non-candy ideas include small toys, crafts, and creative surprises that kids love—and they’re perfect for classrooms, allergy-conscious families, or sugar-free egg hunts.
Most are easy to find in dollar stores or online and fit well inside standard plastic eggs.
Creative and Crafty
- Puffy Stickers
- Dig gem box
- Funky shaped bandaids
- Easter Erasers
- Pencil Top Erasers
- Silly Bandz Pets
- Mini play dough
- Elastic no-tie shoelaces
- Easter Bunny shaped bookmark clip
- Mini notebook
Interactive and Engaging
- Easter scratch off cards
- Finger lights
- Mini chalkboard
- Diving buddies
- Washi tape
- Mini flashlight
- Mini stamp
- Glow in the dark stars
- Sticky hands
- Balloons
Novelty and Fun
- Punch balloon
- Water Balloons
- Grow an animal capsules
- Miniature rubber ducky
- Wind up baby chicks
- Mini chalk
- Bendable animals
- Buildable crayons
- Dollar bills
Easter Egg Fillers for Boys
These non-candy Easter egg fillers for boys are full of action, creativity, and fun. From mini games and puzzles to outdoor toys and silly surprises, they’re perfect for adding variety to your egg hunt—without the sugar rush.
Fun and Games
- Marbles
- Dice
- Temporary tattoos
- Rubber wrist bracelets
- Zoo animal finger puppets
- Toy insects
- Farm animals
- Mini lego set
- Dinosaur fossils
- Easter magnets
- Popper spring launchers
- Mini transformers
- Thinking silly putty
- Lego minifigures
Adventure and Action
- Rocks & fossils
- Lanyard
- Mini yo-yo
- Mini pop it keychain
- Play foam
- Stress ball
- Inflatable beach ball
- Squishes
- Galaxy slime
- Mesh ball
- Puzzle balls
- Mini Rubix cube
- Spring coils
- Fidget snake twist
- Mini fidget toys
- Mini expandable sphere
- Splash ball for the pool
- Mini bubbles
- Mini puzzle box
- Bouncy balls
- Super splashers
Have fun finding the Easter eggs with outdoor rhyming Easter egg hunt clues!
Sports and Outdoor
- Whistle
- NBA bracelet
- Star Wars socks
- Matchbox cars
- Bath bombs for boys
- Mini whoopie cushion
- Toy soldiers
- Superhero slap bracelet
- Parachute men
- Pirate treasure
- Water squirt toy
- Insect finger puppet
- Pull back cars or trucks
- Monster socks
- Pop it bracelet
Easter Egg Fillers for Girls
These non-candy Easter egg fillers for girls include a mix of jewelry, accessories, and playful fantasy items that kids of all ages will enjoy. They’re colorful, fun, and perfectly sized for plastic eggs—making every discovery feel like a tiny surprise gift.
Jewelry and Accessories
- Easter Slap bracelet
- Rainbow shoe laces
- Backpack keychains
- Disney Princess coin purse
- Colorful hairclips
- Jelly bracelets
- Stick on earrings
- Elastic Headband
- Friendship bracelets
- Bandana
- Light up ring
Fashion and Beauty
- Hair ties
- Easter nail stickers
- Scrunchies
- Chapstick
- Hair bows
- Non-toxic nail polish
- Body glitter
- Hair chalk
- Lip balm
- Face mask
Fun and Fantasy
- Mini trolls
- Mini Disney characters
- Beaded necklace
- Friendship zipper bracelets
- Unicorn Beaded bracelet
- Mermaid headband
Have fun finding the Easter eggs with indoor Easter scavenger hunt clues!
Other Easter Gift Ideas
If you’re looking for Easter presents that go beyond what fits inside a plastic egg, these popular gift guides are full of fun and thoughtful ideas—no chocolate required.
- Non chocolate Easter gifts for kids
- Easter gifts for 8 year old boys
- Easter gift for 10 year old boy
- Easter gifts for 13 year old boys
Choosing the Right Plastic Eggs
To fit all these healthy and non-candy Easter egg fillers, stick with standard plastic eggs for most items, and include a few larger ones for bulkier surprises.
Reusable eggs are a practical and eco-friendly option—just store them away for next year’s hunt.
Last Updated on 13 April 2025 by Clare Brown